Barbara Bridges
Empirical/Analytical Paradigm

Also called:

OBJECTIVE-QUANTITATIVE-DEDUCTIVE-NORMATIVE-POSITIVIST-AUTHORITARIAN
(This worldview believes that you can explain-predict-control – Scientists see the world from this perspective.)

Underlying assumptions:
1. Cause and effect is real and can be predicted. 6. Reality exists be predicted
2. Research is context-free 7. Investigation is neutral
3. Believes in detached role of observer 8. Theory and Practice are separate
4. Uses statistical analysis 9. Subject/Object relationship
5. Variables -Aristotle, Locke, Hume – society as a whole - generalize from the specific

TYPES OF RESEARCH MODELS

Developmental - experimental psychology - people respond mechanically
Epistemological - knowledge origin is from without - common goal - known text (universitas)
Experimental - natural science - true knowledge

THEORISTS:
Socrates Teacher leads the learner to the answer by using “artful questioning”
Mortimer Adler All members of the species have the same nature, perrenialist
Aristotle Teacher instructs learner
Albert Bandura People develop behaviors by observing others- behaviorist
Warren Bennis Knowledge is testable by scientific method
Alfred Binet Developer of the IQ test
Benjamin Bloom Bloom’s Taxonomy-Six progressively complex levels of cognition
Auguste Comte Men should recognize the overriding authority of science.
René Descartes Modern school of mathematics
William Glasser Control theory is about fulfilling the needs of the individual
Marian Edelman Children will model what they see.
Erik Erikson 8 stages of psychosocial development
Fredrich Hegel Students must conform to institutional order and laws of reason but believed in self-consciousness – laid foundation for social philosophy
E. D Hirsch Core knowledge exists.
Thomas Hobbes Cause and effect- geometry and physics answers questions without human nature.
David Hume All knowledge comes from experience
Ayn Rand Objectivism is a complete, systematic, integrated system of thought
Bertrand Russell Reality grounded in mathematics-Principia Mathematical
Lawrence Kohlberg Theory of moral development influenced by Jean Piaget and John Dewey
John Locke Knowledge is publicly verifiable, measurable.
Ivan Pavlov Conditioning
Jean Piaget 5 stages of cognitive development
B. F. Skinner Behaviorist, Operant conditioning and schedules of reinforcement
Edward Thorndike Law of Effect, Law of Readiness, Law of Exercise
Lev Vygotsky Scaffolding- private speech
Edmund Husserl Principal founder of phenomenology

THEORETICAL BASE
Assimilationist - Majority rules- absorbs less powerful cultures
Behaviorist - All behavior is a response to stimuli - predictable -B.F. Skinner (Pavlov's dog)
Objectivism - complete, systematic, integrated system of thought
Rationalist - human reason is starting place for construction of knowledge - Descartes
Empiricist - knowledge foundation of human experience
Determinist - no random events - determined by past behaviors and events
Essentialist - hard work, mental discipline, core of knowledge - 3 R's
Structuralist - believes there are societal universal structures
Perrennialist - underlying principles of existence are constant- we can pass on a body of knowledge - Edelman
Positivist - logical -the what - quantitative study of human phenomena - Comte
Realist - concepts exist (not just names) knowledge and values are independent of human mind - Aristotle

METHODS/PROCEDURES/TECHNIQUES
  1. Nomothetic (General laws) – agree on general truths

  2. Survey Verbal or written questions administered to subjects.

  3. Experiment A test measuring an effect.

  4. Randomized Sampling The selection of subjects using a random system.

  5. Pre/post Test A test given before and after the treatment.

  6. Statistical Analysis Correlational studies- one variable’s change is affected by change in another variable.

  7. Correlational Studies - One variable’s change is effected by a change in another variable

  8. Use of Control Group A group that is not given the treatment.

Return to top
Interpretive/Symbolic Paradigm

Also called:

QUALITATIVE-SUBJECTIVE-INDUCTIVE -EXISTENTIALIST- NON-AUTHORITARIAN
(This worldview is idiomatic - individual - nonstatistical - interpretation specific - a snap shot)

Underlying assumptions:

  1. Attempts to understanding

  2. Believes the world is contextual

  3. Observer-participant

  4. Holistic inquiry

  5. Reports out with narrative description

  6. Believes realities are multiple social phenomena

  7. Believes investigation is context laden

  8. Believes theory and practice are interactive, and specific

  9. Subject/Subject relationship

  10. Anthropological approach-ethnography

TYPES OF RESEARCH MODELS

Hermeneutics - paths have fallen together - knowledge from within - study of text

Anthropology - study of culture and social characteristics - Mead

Phenomenology - classify experience at face value - how individuals make sense of world , pre-reflective

Phenomenological Human Science - study of essential meanings of life world –van Manen

Symbolic Interaction - focus on the world of the subjective and the meanings and symbols that represent them - no suggestions for remediation - the now

THEORISTS
Max Van Manen Phenomenological Human Science, practice, reflection
Immanuel Kant German philosopher and founder of Critical Philosophy; made first decisive break with empiricism
Jerome Bruner Students construct new ideas by integrating new material.
Noam Chomsky Students understand the world through the arduous process of controlled inquiry.
John Dewey Grandfather of Pedagogy – Progressivism. Relies upon the use of scientific method to solve problems
W. E. B. DuBois Every argument rests on an unproven postulate.
Elliot Eisner Qualitative research
Frederik Froebel Free self-activity, discovery play.
Howard Gardner Multiple intelligences Linguistic, Musical, Logical, Spatial, Kinesthetic, Intrapersonal, and Interpersonal
Roger and David Johnson Cooperative Learning
Maxine Greene Purpose of education is for teachers and students to create meaning in their lives
Jean-Jacques Rousseau The common, natural man, Emile, original nature of man is good but corrupted by society
Margaret Mead Anthropologist - individual experience of developmental stages could be shaped by cultural demands and expectations
Daniel Golman Emotional Intelligence
William F. Pinar Cultural character of the curriculum
Jean Paul Sartre Existentialism - emphasizes the ultimacy of human freedom
Carl R. Rogers Client-centered therapy-humanist
Martin Heidegger Metaphysics – relativist - social critic - educated in phenomenological tradition of Husserl
Abraham Maslow The father of Humanistic Psychology Hierarchy of Needs
Maria Montessori Education is not what the teacher gives; education is a natural process spontaneously carried out by the human individual

THEORETICAL BASE

"Eastern Thought" - starts with the inner world - reaches to the outer world of thought

Voluntarist - humans exercise free will

Ethnographist - in-depth analysis of a specific cultural situation

Constructionist - believes in intact realities, students develop own frames of thought

Relativist - everything goes, meaningless

Reconceptualist - lived experience (lived experience)

Anti-Positivist - knowledge origin from within- people respond to given situation

Pragmatist - anticipated consequences-informed judgment-becoming (not being) application.

Progressivist - learning is rooted in questions developed by the learners -Process not Product - Dewey

Naturalist - don't disrupt just record and understand axioms: 1. realities are multiple, 2. knower and known are interactive, 3. no generalizations, 4. inductive, no cause and effect, 5. inquiry is value bound, always biased

"Native American Thought" - connection to nature - cyclical oneness

Nominalist - abstract theme - only can name things, never real

Existentialist - reality in the lived experience - Sartre, Kierkegaard

METHODS/PROCEDURES/TECHNIQUES USED FOR RESEARCH
1. Role play 5. Scenario
2. Interview 6. Script taping
3. Participant observation 7. Case study
4. Probing 8. Descriptive Research

Return to top
Critical Paradigm
(This world view attempts to reveal the tacit values that underlie the enterprise or hidden agenda)

Underlying Assumptions of this world view:

  1. Looking for underlying assumptions
  2. Looking for internal contradictions and politics
  3. Advocates social action
  4. Believe society is controlled by power
  5. Believes reality is contextual
  6. Believes self-reflection is the beginning

TYPES OF RESEARCH MODELS

Post Structural Analysis - looking for underlying assumptions
Define Literary Theory
Archaeology
- looking for historical implications
Cultural Criticism - critical sociology or anthropology
Discursive - explore organization or ordinary talk
Hermeneutics - study of known text

THEORISTS

Karl Marx Basic reality is material- knower and known are in a continued process of mutual adaptation.
Henry Girouix Critical Theorist - all things are power and politics
Friedrich Nietzsche Existentialist - facts do not exist, only interpretations
Soren Kierkegaard Existentialism – believed in religion, indirect communication
Jean Paul Sartre Existentialism- a philosophical approach that emphasizes the ultimacy of human freedom.
Paulo Freire Brazilian educator – phenomenologist , students must construct knowledge from knowledge they already possess
Jurgen Habermas Most eclectic modern Marxist - speech act theory, hermeneutics
Michael Apple Educational critical theorist –criticizes education as factory model
Lev Vygotsky Scaffolding- private speech.

THEORETICAL BASE

Feminist Critique - feminist/gender issues

Neo-Pragmatist - concerned with language

Neo-Marxist - maintain most issues in our lives are economic/historical

Critical Theorist - looks at underlying assumptions - contradictions - improve society, synthesis of philosophy and a scientific understanding of society - Habermas

Reductionist - way to understand is to relate to small independent parts

Deconstructionist - analyzes internal contradictions (Norris, Benjamin) language theory

Social Reconstructist - focus is to improve society - Girouix

Post Structuralist - looks at underlying assumptions - no universals - Foucault

Postmodernist - never generalize - each case has its own peculiarities - coming to know is centered on self - role of social critic is to play language game - exchange symbols

Post Positivist - if knowledge exists, use science to describe and find out WHY data appears as it does

Humanistic - humans are born free and good but are enslaved by institutions, individuals are not objects to be measured - Rousseau

METHODS/PROCEDURES/TECHNIQUES

  1. Rhetorical Close Reading - read for multiple levels of reading
  2. Decentering - to move from the center of focus of inquiry - look at relationship not subject/object
  3. Coding/Decoding Text or Verbal - look for code - WHY they use the word
  4. Case Study - a snapshot - focuses on an individual or group
  5. Text Analysis - underlying meanings
  6. Reflection
Return to top
Copyright Barbara Rogers Bridges
No reproductions of any kind may be made without the author's written permission.
Return to Educational Consulting page
E-mail Barbara at: bbridges@bcmn.com
| Barbara Bridges' Biography |
| Art | Educational Consulting | Home |